Silk & Snow vs Douglas
Disclaimer: Top Sleep Picks is owned and operated by Best Sleep Media. Best Sleep Media is part of the organization that owns Casper Canada, Endy, Silk & Snow, Hush and Bloom brands. Brands we own are included in the products reviewed and advertised. The views presented here are our own opinions. Canadian Mattress Experts are paid for their contribution to our content. See full disclosure
Silk & Snow vs Douglas
VS
Silk & Snow S&S
Douglas Original
If you've been in the market for a Canadian-made mattress, chances are you've encountered Silk & Snow and Douglas. Combining the plush comfort and pressure relief of foam with superior motion isolation abilities, all-foam mattresses cater to a variety of sleep preferences. While there are similarities between Silk & Snow and Douglas Original models, our team conducted a thorough comparison. In the end, the S&S Mattress emerged as the preferred choice. Keep reading to discover why.
Best Mattress in Canada
|
||
|
|
|
| Mattress Price* |
Mattress Price*
$800 CAD |
Mattress Price*
$799 CAD |
| Duvet |
Duvet
Free |
Duvet
Not Included |
| 2 PIllows |
2 PIllows
Free |
2 PIllows
Included |
| Sheet Set |
Sheet Set
Free |
Sheet Set
Included |
| Mattress Protector |
Mattress Protector
Free |
Mattress Protector
Included |
| Material |
Material
|
Material
|
| Origin |
Origin
Canadian company |
Origin
Canadian company |
| Number of Happy Sleepers |
Number of Happy Sleepers
300,000+ |
Number of Happy Sleepers
200,000+ |
| 0% 1 yr Financing in Canada |
0% 1 yr Financing in Canada
Yes |
0% 1 yr Financing in Canada
No |
| Firmness |
Firmness
Various Options |
Firmness
One Option - Medium Soft |
| Google Business Rating |
Google Business Rating
4.4 (1000+ real customer reviews) |
Google Business Rating
Does not list business |
| In-Store Shopping |
In-Store Shopping
Available at |
In-Store Shopping
No |
| Online Shopping |
Online Shopping
silkandsnow.com
eq3.com |
Online Shopping
douglas.ca
goodmorning.com |
| Veritree Reforestation Program |
Veritree Reforestation Program
Yes
Planting 150,000 trees in Williams Lake, BC |
Veritree Reforestation Program
None |
| GlacialAir™ Cooling Foam |
GlacialAir™ Cooling Foam
Yes |
GlacialAir™ Cooling Foam
No |
| Sleep Trial |
Sleep Trial
365 |
Sleep Trial
365 |
| Warranty |
Warranty
15 years |
Warranty
20 years |
| Standout Features |
Standout Features
|
Standout Features
|
| SHOP NOW |
All information listed above was compiled from publicly available sources and is accurate as of July 29, 2024.
*Price based on the MSRP of the S&S Mattress in size Queen compared to the MSRP of the Douglas Original Mattress in size Queen
*Price based on the MSRP of the S&S Mattress in size Queen compared to the MSRP of the Douglas Original Mattress in size Queen
Which Mattress Should You Buy?
Based on our comprehensive analysis, we strongly recommend choosing the S&S Mattress over the Douglas Original option. Throughout our testing process, the S&S Mattress consistently outperformed its counterpart in several key areas. It excelled in motion isolation, provided superior support for all sleep positions, and offered a cooler and more comfortable sleeping experience.
After evaluating both mattresses over a hundred nights of use, we can confidently affirm the numerous 5-star reviews for the S&S Mattress. This mattress delivers an exceptional blend of plushness and support, proving its durability across various sleeping positions.
We observed that Douglas’ mattress developed a hump in the middle, a common issue attributed to improper "break-in" as mentioned in their FAQ. In contrast, the S&S Mattress maintained its integrity and comfort throughout our testing period. Despite both mattresses being composed of memory foam, the S&S Mattress outperformed the Douglas.
Overall, the S&S Mattress impressed our team and earned our unequivocal endorsement for individuals seeking the finest Canadian-made mattress.
Construction
Silk & Snow S&S
1. Antimicrobial cover
Conventional mattresses can be the perfect environments for the growth of yeast, mold, mites, and bacteria. The S&S Mattress offers a solution with its high-quality, integrated antimicrobial cover. This feature helps to inhibit the growth of bacteria, safeguarding both you and your mattress against unhygienic conditions.
2. Easy to remove cover
The top of the mattress cover zips off easily, so that keeping your mattress clean doesn’t have to be a chore.
3. GlacialAir® Foam
Crafted with meticulous hand-stitching, the premium, dense 4lb memory foam is infused with cooling gel to regulate climate and enhance plushness. This feature ensures a consistent and comfortable temperature for a restful night's sleep.
4. Support & Motion Isolation
Experience profound pressure point relief with the 1.8 lb transitional performance foam for unparalleled
5. Durability
Feel the support of 1.8 lb premium support layer for a durable foundation
Douglas Original
1. CoolSense® Cover
A washable cover that draws moisture away, leading to a cool, dry night.
2. ecoLight® Cooling Gel Foam
Cooling gel foam that is durable, responsive, and luxurious as high-density memory foam but won’t retain heat or feel like quicksand.
3. Premium Elastex Foam
This 2” foam piece mimics the support and responsive properties of latex.
4. Motion Isolation Support Foam
6” support foam effectively eliminates motion transfer between sleepers.
Comfort
Best Overall
Silk & Snow
The comfort of the S&S Mattress is unparalleled. The brand’s new innovative design for their beloved original model packs a punch, boasting soft cushioning and body contouring foam layers and a supportive, foundational base. Most notably, the dense 4lb GlacialAir® Foam offers pressure point relief where it matters most-promoting spinal alignment for a restorative sleep.
Douglas
In comparison, the Douglas Original mattress was underwhelming. Our testers consistently reported a sinking feeling while sleeping that becomes more pronounced with usage, offering weaker support to your spine over time. However, those who prefer a softer mattress, or love 100% memory foam mattress, may be partial to the Douglas Original in comparison to firmer models from competitors.
Motion Transfer
When sharing a bed with a partner or pet, ensuring minimal motion transfer is essential for a restful sleep. Some mattresses may exhibit bouncing or shaking when one person moves during the night or gets up and down. To assess this, we conducted a motion isolation test by placing a vessel of colored water on each mattress and observing its stability during various movements.
Overall, Silk & Snow’s S&S Mattress demonstrated superior motion isolation compared to the other mattress in this comparison.
Best Overall
Silk & Snow
The S&S Mattress demonstrated little to no movement in the water vessel when the tester sat on the bed, adjusted for their side sleeping position, and then got back up. Based on our observations, we anticipate that individual sleepers would experience minimal disturbance from their partner or pet sharing the mattress.
Douglas
The Douglas Original exhibited minimal to some movement in the water vessel when the tester got on and off the bed. For individuals who share a mattress, it’s expected that some movement may be felt by the sleeper. Therefore, we wouldn’t recommend this mattress for light sleepers who are particularly sensitive to disturbances.
Breathability
The breathability of a mattress plays a crucial role in facilitating air circulation and dissipating heat, ultimately contributing to a cooler and more comfortable sleeping environment. While both mattresses boast air circulation and sweat-wicking capabilities, the S&S Mattress stands out for its superior breathability, thanks to its utilization of non-toxic fabrics and an antimicrobial layer. In particular, the high-quality quilted foam effectively eliminates heat retention, ensuring that you’ll find a cool surface wherever you rest.
Conclusion
After a comprehensive analysis of our sleep testers’ feedback and a thorough examination of each mattress’s specifications, the S&S Mattress emerges as the clear winner in this comparison.
Priced at $799 CAD for a Queen mattress, the Douglas Original presents an affordable option from a Canadian company, featuring cooling and supportive foam. However, there are concerns regarding the transparency of material sourcing, with some disclosures indicating that parts of the mattress are manufactured in China and assembled in Canada. Additionally, while the mattress boasts a 10-inch profile, this height doesn’t necessarily translate to enhanced support or comfort.
On the other hand, the S&S Mattress stands out as a 100% Canadian-made model, with transparent information available regarding material sourcing and production. Its multi-layer plush memory foam construction, coupled with an antimicrobial cover, provides a pain-relieving cradle for the body, ensuring durability and long-lasting support. Priced at $800 CAD for a Queen, the S&S Mattress delivers a superior sleeping experience and offers better overall value.
